OK, so I was speaking a while ago with a colleague, and we were sort of
joking about Yigdal (the liturgical restatement of Rambam's 13
Principles of Faith), that we hoped that it was graded on a curve,
because otherwise, neither of us were sure we could get a passing grade on that
test-- much less 100%.
It started out just as a joke, but it got me thinking: my supposition is
that most non-Orthodox Jews probably couldn't get a score of over 60%
on the "Do You Believe These 13 Principles?" quiz, and even the ones to which they're willing to answer "yes" probably have some unspoken
reservations attached.
To some degree, I think that's inevitable. Two Jews, three opinions: we
all know that, and that's probably a very lowball estimate when theology is
involved.
Granted, I think Rambam never meant the 13 Principles to be an
exact catechistic checklist, to be formalized as universal Jewish dogma
(and indeed it never has been, nor do we have any such thing); and I
wouldn't approve of there being such a thing anyhow.
But it would kind
of be useful as a short-hand in theological conversations, I think, to
have something like that as a reference point for discussion.
So with probably an earth-shaking lack of proper humility, I took it
upon myself to try and update the Rambam's list. I fully admit that not
only am I no Rambam, I am not even remotely close, and should anyone
wish to accuse me of humongous chutzpah, I am cheerfully willing to
accept such a judgment. I am also very aware that my update is
predicated on the ideas both of a personal God and some form of halachic
commandedness, which not all non-Orthodox Jews agree with; and I am
(less cheerfully) willing to accept that as a fair criticism and leave it at that, because I actually don't see a way around God being personal, and I feel quite strongly about the need for halachah in some form or another.
To be honest, I have no idea whether it is even reasonable to expect
that Jews could have as many as thirteen theological points on which
they might roughly, in some way shape or form, agree with a majority. Hell, it might be a pipe dream to think we could expect more than three or four, tops. But since (chatzpan that I am) I thought it best to follow Rambam's list as well as I might, there remain 13, and some are even more or less the same.
I have to say, I have renewed respect for Rambam (if such a thing were even necessary) after engaging in this project: it's awfully hard to come up with concise statements of faith that are both specific enough to be meaningful and at the same time loose enough to permit them to be umbrellas for numerous shades of interpretation, some spaced rather far apart from each other. And, to be fair, in that interest I did change the format from "I believe with perfect faith" to just "I believe," because honestly, can anyone really claim perfect faith about anything? Never a single moment's doubt? No reservations, no exceptions, no wavering? If we're very, very lucky, maybe we could claim that about one thing. Maybe. But more than that, and either we're kidding ourselves or we're nuts, or so I would think.
In any case, here they are (though I have yet to translate them properly into Hebrew, so forgive me):
1. I believe that
the Holy One Blessed Be He, is the Creator and Designer of everything
that has been created; He alone is responsible for the conception and
creation ex nihilo of this and any other universes, and the design and
ultimate causation of everything within them, and anything besides
Himself that might exist outside them.
2. I believe that the Holy One
Blessed Be He, and blessed be His Name, is One, and that there is no
other unity in any way like His, and that He alone is God, who was, and
is, and will be.
3. I believe that the Holy One
Blessed Be He, has no physical body or characteristics thereof, nor
anything even remotely resembling such, and that there can be no
physical comparison to Him whatsoever.
4. I believe that the Holy One
Blessed Be He, is the first and the last: nothing preceded Him, and
nothing shall outlast Him, for He alone is eternal and not created; and
all else in existence was created by Him, and endures at His pleasure.
5. I believe that the Holy One
Blessed Be He is capable of omniscience, omnipotence, and omnipresence,
but contracts Himself for the sake of the existence of the universe, and
for the sake of the gift of free will to human beings.
6. I believe that to the the Holy
One Blessed Be He, and to Him alone, it is right to pray; and that it is
not right to pray to any being or object besides Him.
7. I believe in the covenant of
Torah, in the form of the Written Torah that we have passed down from
time of our leaving Egypt and which was canonized by Ezra the Prophet,
and the Oral Torah that we have received from Our Rabbis of Blessed
Memory and which we continue to create. We are bound to the Holy One
Blessed Be He through Torah: we receive it, in order to follow the
mitzvot within it, as it is written, “And the People said to Moshe:
everything that Hashem commands, we will do and we will hear;” (Ex.
24:7) and in order to create more Torah and more fully comprehend the
mitzvot, as it is taught “Rabbi Yehudah rose to his feet and said: ‘It
is not in Heaven!’ (Deut. 30:12) What did he mean by ‘It is not in
Heaven?’ Rabbi Yirmiyah explained: That the Torah had already been given
at Sinai, and we do not pay attention to further revelatory material,
but rather, as it is written, ‘We rule according to the majority [of
halachic scholars].’ (Ex. 23:2)” (BT Bava Metzia 59b)
8. I believe that the covenant of
Torah is eternal and irreplaceable, and while interpretations may change
and halachah may evolve, there is no addition to the Written Torah, nor
are there new revelations that add to the revelations of our prophets,
whose day ended at the time of the raising of the Second Temple, and
whose like shall not be seen again until the time of the moshiach.
9. I believe that observance of the
mitzvot is incumbent upon all the People Israel, according to our
various interpretations of the halachah; and that it is the duty of all
Jews to learn and study Torah, both Written and Oral, all their days, so
that they may know our inheritance and understand their obligations and
wrestle with the infinite meanings implicit in Torah, and thus both
fulfill the commandment “You shall love Hashem your God with all your
heart and all your soul and all your might...” (Deut. 6:5), and be
worthy of the name of Yisra’el (the one who struggles with God).
10. I believe that Judaism alone is the
religion for Jews, and is not to be replaced by or conflated with
non-Jewish religions. Nor is it to be universalized and actively
proselytized to non-Jews, who can and should have their own paths for
relating to the the Holy One Blessed Be He and establishing justice on
the earth.
11. I believe that the the Holy One
Blessed Be He, knows perfectly who has done right and who has done
wrong, and confronts all beings at some point with the accounting of
their deeds, and that for evil there are some form of consequences, and
for good there is some form of reward, and the one need not preclude the
other, nor shall we know with certainty what either may be, so long as
we live upon this earth.
12. I believe in the coming of the the time of the moshiach; that such a time shall come about after the achievement of tikkun olam:
when the hungry shall be fed, and the poor shall be clothed and housed;
when the helpless are helped and the downfallen upraised; when peace is
made and war is no longer, as it is written, “Nation shall not lift up
sword against nation, nor shall they practice war any more,” (Is. 2:4)
and when the People Israel shall once again be able to live safely in
all the land that was promised to our ancestors (regardless of whose
flag may fly over parts of it); and when we can agree among ourselves
and our neighbor brethren upon the building of a Third Temple, on the
holy mountain of Hashem-- a Temple unlike the first two, as it is
written, “My House shall be a House of Prayer for all nations;” (Is.
56:7) then shall it be the time of the moshiach.
13. I believe that the soul that the
Holy One Blessed Be He places within each one of us is eternal, and
survives beyond the confines of this world, even if we do not know for
certain to what places it may travel afterward, as it is written “I
shall not die, but rather, live, and speak of the deeds of Hashem.” (Ps.
118:17)
-Ami
Sunday, March 11, 2012
Monday, March 5, 2012
Amish Torah
Having been out of blogging action for a couple of weeks due
to the interference of life, this week brings two posts, right after one
another.
Recently, Julie and I took a quick two-day getaway to
Indiana (which we can’t recommend), to Amish country (which we can recommend
highly).
We learned a lot about the Amish while we were there. I knew
very little about them, prior to this trip: only that they were Anabaptists (a
Christian belief wherein baptism of a child at birth or in early childhood is
considered insufficient, and a second baptism at maturity is deemed necessary,
because they believe acceptance of salvation requires kavanah [intent] to be a ma’aseh
[effective deed]-- although they don’t put it quite like that). I knew that
they lived separately, and (I thought) entirely rejected technology much past
the level of around the seventeenth century.
But it turns out that while they do live comparatively
separately, and there are indeed many aspects of technology they reject, they
have a complex system of rules and guidelines for what kinds of technology are
entirely forbidden, and what can be used but not owned, and what can they
neither own nor use themselves but can derive hana’ah (“enjoyment” or profit) from in its use by an English
person (in Amish parlance, all non-Amish people are called English, which suits
me well, since I have always sort of wanted to be English anyhow). In short,
they have a de facto system of halachah. And in many ways, as far as I have
been able to tell, it has many parallels to hilchot
Shabbat (the halachot of Shabbat observance) and hilchot aku”m (the halachot of dealing with non-Jews).
For example, our Amish host took us for a brief ride in his
buggy (I felt a little sorry for the single horse pulling four of us in a wooden
buggy, but she seemed to be fairly fatalistic about the experience): though the
buggy itself is “handmade” wood, drawn by a horse, it has running lights for
night-time driving which are electric, powered by batteries. Also, we noted
that though there were no electronic devices in the spacious
sitting-room/dining room that we were entertained in, our hosts did have a
refrigerator, powered by natural gas (also a gas stove/range, and gas lamps,
which were cool, like being in a 19th century parlor).
It turns out that they are prohibited from being connected
to the electrical grid (part of their living “separate” lives), and so shun
major electrical appliances or electronic devices. But they have no prohibition
about natural gas power (though they are not connected to gas lines, but use
large storage tanks instead), and they make exceptions to the electric
appliance rule for some small things, especially those which can be powered by
batteries and cranks (we didn’t get to ask about solar or wind, although those
kind of seem like they should be permitted-- but then, what do I know from
Amish halachah? There’s plenty of things in our halachah that seem like they
ought to be permitted, but are not, or occasionally vice-versa). And they will use even from-the-grid
electricity if they are working for an English person, and it is done in their place
of business. They will accept car rides from English people, and even charter
buses for communal trips.
The atmosphere of the Amish dinner table (and they were
lovely hosts, though Julie and I couldn’t really eat most of what they served--
they like their fleischigs, which of course are treyf) was convivial, warm,
welcoming, friendly, familial, and full of storytelling and joking. In sum,
much like a frum dinner table.
We learned that these very plain-living folks who were our
hosts, unable to have children (in a prolific culture with significant stigma
attached to infertility, much like the frum world), had adopted and raised
seven kids. We had to learn from our mutual friend that they hadn’t mentioned
the twenty kids whom they had fostered over the eyars.
And it got me thinking, how like and how unlike Haredi Jews
the Amish are. The Haredi world has some really good qualities, some of the
best being their willingness to open their homes and their hands to aid those
around them (even when they themselves might have little), and the tight knit
communitarianism that helps keep frum kids educated in frum schools, keeps frum
shul memberships free or on sliding scales, keeps food on everyone’s plate for
Shabbos. In that sense, they are much like the Amish. The only people I have
known whom I would’ve bet would raise seven adopted kids have been frum.
But the big difference I noted was that the Amish understand
and acknowledge that their lifestyle and their rules are chumrot that they take upon themselves. They acknowledge that one
need not be Amish to be a good person, or even a good Christian. It is their
way, and it is not for everyone. It is deeply ironic, I think, that this
attitude, so similar to how we as Jews approach the idea of conversion and
Judaism (in other words, we don’t proselytize, and we don’t necessarily rush to
encourage converts, because we understand that one need not be Jewish to be a
good person and please God), is so utterly at variance with how Haredim
understand Haredi Judaism. Built upon a vast network of ever-denser chumrot, ascetic minhagim derived from mussar
and mussar-influenced Kabbalistic
teachings, and stultifyingly paralytic interpretations of halachah, Haredi
Judaism nonetheless sees itself as entirely authentic and normative, the beau
ideal from which all other forms of Judaism are deviant.
As devoted to interfaith dialogue as I am, it still
sometimes shocks me when I come across a particularly blatant example of how
Jews can need a lesson in Torah from non-Jews.
The Amish, without having any knowledge of the concept as we
have it, have put into practice the idea from Eruvin 13b of elu v’elu divrei elohim chayim (“these
and also those are the words of the Living God.” They have put into practice
the belief that one should take upon oneself and one’s community a set of
strictures for a purer, more ascetic life, while retaining the awareness that
doing so is a choice, not a matter of universal requirement: and that, my
friends, is tolerance. That is the knowledge-in-action that pluralism creates shalom bayit (internal peace) in the
community at large.
You take a look at what’s going on with the Haredi world in
Israel, between the Orthodox and non-Orthodox communities there and here in the
US. And you tell me that Haredim don’t need what the Amish have to teach. It is
a lesson that would lead us steps closer on the path to tikkun olam, and bringing the coming of the moshiach.
-Ami
Tuesday, January 31, 2012
Jewish Education Comes From Home
I just started a new teaching gig: learning Megillat Ruth
with a small class of high school girls every Sunday. And I was pleasantly
surprised to find that my new students were extremely bright, had acute
literary skills, and excellent Hebrew. They translated, they read, they
discussed, all with speed, quality, and incisiveness...it was the kind of
experience learning text with students that Jewish educators rarely get the
chance to have.
Afterward, I was musing to myself about the class, wondering
why this was so different. It’s not, of course, like I’ve never taught very
bright, talented kids before. You can’t teach in Jewish day schools and Hebrew
schools and not run into a lot of bright and talented kids. But these girls
were remarkable, in my experience: I have seldom taught such a responsive and
engaged class.
In the end, it was the engagement that struck me as being
most different. They did so well not only because they were bright and
talented, but because they were engaged, they were motivated. They wanted to be
there, learning what they were learning. And to some degree, that might just be
because all or some of them have a natural inclination for text study.
But to a very great degree, it became apparent to me, having
met their parents, having seen those parents interacting with their children,
that the girls were engaged and motivated because their parents were engaged,
and were teaching by example that, in their homes, Jewish learning was
important, and to be valued for its own sake; and that such learning was
connected to life in that home, by virtue of observance. In whatever shape or
form it might take, it was clear to me that these were homes that observed
Shabbat and chagim (festivals) and perhaps had some kind of experience of
kashrut. I’m not implying Orthodoxy or any kind of strict traditionalism; just
that these were homes in which Judaism was readily participatory in some
fashion. And I believe that has made all the difference.
I am a Jewish educator. My rabbinate is teaching. I’ve taught
in day school, in Hebrew school, at informal learning gatherings, and
one-on-one for tutoring of various kinds. I spend a lot of my time thinking
about how to teach more effectively, what we as a community or as a people
could be doing to improve Jewish educational facilities or train better Jewish
educators. But things like teaching this wonderful class remind me that
ultimately, even if we had the kind of funding that we need (and always lack)
to make quality Jewish education readily available and affordable, even if we
had consistently deeply informed and traditionally knowledgeable teachers, the
better part of the onus for successful Jewish education rests upon the home.
I have taught classes, in the past, that were the reverse of
this one that I recently began. Where the kids absolutely didn’t want to be
there, they steadfastly refused to participate, their knowledge of both text
and Hebrew was abysmal, and those that lacked utter apathy for the Jewish
tradition only replaced apathy with vague contempt. And perhaps in part, we can
write some of that off to modern teenagerhood: rebellious, apathetic,
disconnected. But having met the parents of those students also, I know that
they had homes in which Jewish observance played no real part: Shabbat was not
kept, and such chagim as were kept were observed in the most casual and
half-hearted manner; text was not discussed or learned in the home, and no form
of kashrut was kept. In short, there was nothing in the home life of these
students that might reinforce or support the notions that the study of Jewish
text and tradition related in any way to real life, or was of any practical
importance to their parents.
I once had such a student tell me with complete seriousness,
when I asked her why she was in Hebrew school, that her mother had been quite
clear that when she (her mother) had been a girl, she’d had to “waste her
afternoons sitting through Hebrew school,” and if she’d had to do it, then her
daughter would have to do it, too. It’s true that we talk a lot about passing
things on l’dor va-dor (from
generation to generation), but I’m pretty sure this is not what that’s supposed
to be.
There seems to be a pretty clear understanding in secular
American culture that if we want our kids to succeed in regular school, not
only does the school need adequate funding, trained teachers, and decent
materials, but parents have to be involved. They need to ensure that kids do
homework, get tutoring if needed, and they need to be given encouragement,
shown that education is valuable, and, ideally, come from a home where books
and newspapers are read, current events are discussed, literature or history or
science or mathematics are used and discussed and valued. In homes where none
of these things are true, it is rare that the child will truly embrace learning
and critical thinking.
It should be obvious that the same basic ideas are true for
Jewish education.
It’s not enough that we send our kids to Hebrew school
(which is seldom an adequate educational experience even in ideal
circumstances), or even to day school. Judaism is passed on by Judaism being
practiced. When kids see mitzvot being done by their parents, when they see
Jewish ritual as a part of their daily (or at least weekly) lives, when they
hear Torah being talked about-- even if it’s just a quick read of the weekly
parashah-- that makes all the difference. When they get support and
encouragement for their Jewish educational achievements equal or greater to
that which they get for their secular educational achievement, that makes all
the difference. In such situations, regardless of the level of home observance
according to the stricture of the tradition, Judaism is a reality, a living
thing, and it causes the student to engage in their Jewish studies. It makes
Jewish education merely a Herculean effort, rather than a Sisyphean effort--
and sometimes, as with my newly begun class, it even makes it into a pleasure
and an instant success.
We Jewish educators need to make a bargain with the rest of
Am Yisrael: we will give 110%-- really bust our butts-- coming up with quality
Jewish educational experiences for your kids. We will bring to bear all our
excitement and passion for our texts and traditions, all our dedication to youth
and education. We will try to make do on the shoestring budgets and limited
resources that education in an economic crisis and an atmosphere of
assimilation permit us. We will continue to teach for shockingly low pay, just
like other teachers, all across America. But in return, zay dem yidn: live Jewish lives. Bring Jewish observance into your
homes. Go to shul on Shabbat. Learn a little Torah. Maybe keep a little kosher.
Say a brachah now and then. These things have limitless effect on your
children. And they will give life to our tradition as nothing else will do so,
strengthening the next generation and elevating us all just a little in
holiness.
-Ami
Friday, January 27, 2012
Revelation-Ritual-Rules-Remembering
When I would teach high school Jewish Studies classes, I would usually give them an assignment around Pesach time: rent Cecil B. DeMille’s The Ten Commandments and Dreamworks’ Prince of Egypt, and after watching them, tell me what they got wrong vis-à-vis the text of the Exodus narrative in the Torah.
It’s a fun little assignment, and the responses it generates are interesting, as a teacher. Prince of Egypt is the harder one for most students, because it’s a better movie, and incorporates much more directly from Torah and from traditional midrashim and commentaries. But what always surprised me is the thing that most students missed, which to me was the most egregious failing of the film. Maybe you’ll recall: the final plague, the “destroyer” moving through Egypt, striking down firstborn, the Israelites, protected, trembling in their dark houses.... Yeah, there’s the problem: where’s the matzah? During the tenth plague, we weren’t trembling in the dark in our protected houses: we were having the first Pesach seder.
Part of what I cherish about this section of the Exodus narrative-- which we see in this week’s parashah, Bo-- is that it does something quintessentially, paradigmatically Jewish. Right as the tenth plague is about to occur, at the dramatic climax of the first act of the Exodus story (the second act being the part about kri’at yam suf, the splitting of the Sea of Reeds, and the third act being the part about getting the Torah at Sinai), the narrative pauses so that God can have Moshe Rabbeinu (our teacher Moses) instruct the people in the basic laws of the Jewish calendar and proper Seder observance.
I love that. I love it because there is something so Jewish, so hamische (homey), about this attitude. That God would say to Moshe, “Listen, dude, I’m gonna send in the destroyer, this plague is gonna be a mind-blower, one for the ages. It’s gonna be so heavy duty.... BTW, make sure you know how to calculate the months, so that you know when all the chagim (holidays) are going to be. The first one’s going to be Pesach: let me give you the details of how to observe it.”
It’s that attitude that really exemplifies our tradition: Something cosmically momentous has occurred, something that should inspire us forever-- but since inspiration can’t be codified and demanded, here’s the tachlis (pragmatic forms) for creating a situation that, if done right, may cause inspiration by reminding you of what occurred and how to connect to it.
That presumption, that the minutiae of ritual and ethical observance are not distinct from revelation and miracle, they proceed directly from revelation and miracle-- and do so not after long separation from the fact, but davka right smack in the middle of the fact...that, my friends, is the heart of the Jewish tradition.
I like to imagine the first Seder, happening while the tenth plague was going on, as a bunch of us gathered around the fireplace, eating roast lamb, matzah, and maror, simultaneously stunned at the advent of our freedom after so long, and bemused at the detailed commandments we now have to keep. I presume that the original Seder involved just as many questions as modern Sedarim do-- maybe that was also the night that originated “Two Jews, three opinions.”
But all jokes aside, what I love about this instance is that it demonstrates the nature of our tradition as one really made to be used by people in their everyday lives. Yes, there are a lot of details in the mitzvot, but they’re there for good reason. And that reason is not, as some have said, “Because God said so,” (which, when I hear it, always sounds like “Because God said so, so shut up.”) but rather because the tradition-- and because God (with whom we author the tradition)-- understands that a person cannot live their life in a perpetual state of revelation, or high spiritual elevation. That’s just not how we function. Nobody exists in a perpetual I-Thou moment. So we need a framework of mitzvot to give us a system of spiritual discipline, to be a daily mnemonic aid, so that we are constantly reminding ourselves of who we are, who we were, and Who made us what we are; so that we can constantly renew, as Heschel put it, our “radical amazement” at life in the universe, at life with one another; so that we create situations, using ritual, that help us re-enact the revelations and miracles that shaped us, so that they continue to shape us.
The Haggadah reminds us of this very thing, midrashically riffing off verses from Parashat Bo:
Such an expectation could not reasonably be supported in a vacuum. Time creates distance. Stories evolve if left unfixed. Revelation cannot be passed on verbally. But with ritual-- both of action and of language-- we create guides to aid us in fixing stories and erasing the distance of passing time, and circumstances to pass on the experience of revelation as much as such a thing can be passed on. The mitzvot of our tradition are potent with understanding of how humanity really functions.
And I love them for it. I value it every day, and every time I read this parashah, and even every time I get annoyed with movie versions of the Exodus for their not getting it right. This understanding in our mitzvot is what gives our people vitality, the life of the millennia, and is a great part of what makes Torah so precious as a way of life: it knows us, sometimes even more than we know it.
-Ami
It’s a fun little assignment, and the responses it generates are interesting, as a teacher. Prince of Egypt is the harder one for most students, because it’s a better movie, and incorporates much more directly from Torah and from traditional midrashim and commentaries. But what always surprised me is the thing that most students missed, which to me was the most egregious failing of the film. Maybe you’ll recall: the final plague, the “destroyer” moving through Egypt, striking down firstborn, the Israelites, protected, trembling in their dark houses.... Yeah, there’s the problem: where’s the matzah? During the tenth plague, we weren’t trembling in the dark in our protected houses: we were having the first Pesach seder.
Part of what I cherish about this section of the Exodus narrative-- which we see in this week’s parashah, Bo-- is that it does something quintessentially, paradigmatically Jewish. Right as the tenth plague is about to occur, at the dramatic climax of the first act of the Exodus story (the second act being the part about kri’at yam suf, the splitting of the Sea of Reeds, and the third act being the part about getting the Torah at Sinai), the narrative pauses so that God can have Moshe Rabbeinu (our teacher Moses) instruct the people in the basic laws of the Jewish calendar and proper Seder observance.
I love that. I love it because there is something so Jewish, so hamische (homey), about this attitude. That God would say to Moshe, “Listen, dude, I’m gonna send in the destroyer, this plague is gonna be a mind-blower, one for the ages. It’s gonna be so heavy duty.... BTW, make sure you know how to calculate the months, so that you know when all the chagim (holidays) are going to be. The first one’s going to be Pesach: let me give you the details of how to observe it.”
It’s that attitude that really exemplifies our tradition: Something cosmically momentous has occurred, something that should inspire us forever-- but since inspiration can’t be codified and demanded, here’s the tachlis (pragmatic forms) for creating a situation that, if done right, may cause inspiration by reminding you of what occurred and how to connect to it.
That presumption, that the minutiae of ritual and ethical observance are not distinct from revelation and miracle, they proceed directly from revelation and miracle-- and do so not after long separation from the fact, but davka right smack in the middle of the fact...that, my friends, is the heart of the Jewish tradition.
I like to imagine the first Seder, happening while the tenth plague was going on, as a bunch of us gathered around the fireplace, eating roast lamb, matzah, and maror, simultaneously stunned at the advent of our freedom after so long, and bemused at the detailed commandments we now have to keep. I presume that the original Seder involved just as many questions as modern Sedarim do-- maybe that was also the night that originated “Two Jews, three opinions.”
But all jokes aside, what I love about this instance is that it demonstrates the nature of our tradition as one really made to be used by people in their everyday lives. Yes, there are a lot of details in the mitzvot, but they’re there for good reason. And that reason is not, as some have said, “Because God said so,” (which, when I hear it, always sounds like “Because God said so, so shut up.”) but rather because the tradition-- and because God (with whom we author the tradition)-- understands that a person cannot live their life in a perpetual state of revelation, or high spiritual elevation. That’s just not how we function. Nobody exists in a perpetual I-Thou moment. So we need a framework of mitzvot to give us a system of spiritual discipline, to be a daily mnemonic aid, so that we are constantly reminding ourselves of who we are, who we were, and Who made us what we are; so that we can constantly renew, as Heschel put it, our “radical amazement” at life in the universe, at life with one another; so that we create situations, using ritual, that help us re-enact the revelations and miracles that shaped us, so that they continue to shape us.
The Haggadah reminds us of this very thing, midrashically riffing off verses from Parashat Bo:
בכל דור ודור חיב אדם לראות את עצמו, כאלו הוא יצא ממצרים, שנאמר: והגדת לבנך ביום ההוא לאמר: בעבור זה עשה ה' לי, בצאתי ממצרים. לא את אבותינו בלבד, גאל הקדוש ברוך הוא, אלא אף אותנו גאל עמהם, שנאמר: ואותנו הוציא משם, למען הביא אתנו, לתת לנו את הארץ אשר נשבע לאבתינוIn every generation, a person must view themselves as if they themselves came forth out of Egypt. As it is said, “And you shall tell your child at that time, saying, ‘It is because of what Hashem did for me when I was brought forth out of Egypt.’” Not were our ancestors alone redeemed by the Holy One Blessed Be He, but we ourselves were redeemed along with them, as it is said, “And He brought us forth from there, so that he could bring us here, to give to us the land which He had sworn to our ancestors.”
Such an expectation could not reasonably be supported in a vacuum. Time creates distance. Stories evolve if left unfixed. Revelation cannot be passed on verbally. But with ritual-- both of action and of language-- we create guides to aid us in fixing stories and erasing the distance of passing time, and circumstances to pass on the experience of revelation as much as such a thing can be passed on. The mitzvot of our tradition are potent with understanding of how humanity really functions.
And I love them for it. I value it every day, and every time I read this parashah, and even every time I get annoyed with movie versions of the Exodus for their not getting it right. This understanding in our mitzvot is what gives our people vitality, the life of the millennia, and is a great part of what makes Torah so precious as a way of life: it knows us, sometimes even more than we know it.
-Ami
Parashat Bo
Barbara McClintock was
a Nobel Prize winning genetic scientist who spent her life studying ears of
corn. She was one of the most precise empirical observers and rigorously
logical thinkers
in American science. But, towards the end of her life, when she was asked “how
do you do great science?” she answered, "about the only thing I can tell you about the
doing of science is that you somehow have to have a feeling for the organism". In thinking about the ears of corn that she
worked with all of her life, she added, "Really, all I can tell you about doing great
science is that you somehow have to lean into the kernel."
I read about McClintock
in a book called, The Heart of Learning: Spirituality in Education, in
an article by a great educator and writer, Parker J. Palmer. In his article, Palmer relates, "Barbara McClintock practiced the highest form
of love – which is intimacy which does not annihilate difference". It’s awesome to think
about this idea of intimacy which does not annihilate difference as it
relates to the art of being an effective teacher. When we teach, we must often attend to the diverse needs
of many individual students with distinct learning styles and personalities.
In McClintock’s work,
her focus was on the individual ears, or sometimes even kernels of corn. What makes us effective is our
ability to “lean into the kernels” in our own lives – or to “somehow have a
feeling for” the individual student, or person, or task,
we face? In McClintock’s words, we
must seek intimacy which does not annihilate difference.
A few years ago I taught a Bat Mitzvah student how to chant from the
Torah. Teaching Torah chanting to
12 and 13 year old kids is something I’ve done since I was in high school. But this time was different: my student was severely hearing
impaired. My inclination was to allow her to
read from the Torah without learning how to chant. But the rabbi of the synagogue urged me to teach her to chant Torah
– just to teach her differently than I’d taught the other kids.
Our Torah portion this
week teaches a similar lesson. In
Exodus 10:2, we read about the obligation of teaching the generations that
follow about the Exodus from slavery in Egypt. We must, “tell it in the ears of your children
and grandchildren”.
This
description is of a very intimate, very personalized telling! It is individualized – it requires really knowing the person you’re
talking to. Saying something “in
the ears”
of someone else is not simply saying to, “teach it to them” – rather, it’s a quiet
telling: deeply personal, meaningful, and sacred.
In the Book of Exodus, the end goal of “telling it into the ears” (of our students) is not just so that they might gain knowledge of the event of the Exodus. It’s much more profound and much more powerful than that. The verse continues, saying that we must tell it into their ears, “and you will (both) know that I am God”.
In the Book of Exodus, the end goal of “telling it into the ears” (of our students) is not just so that they might gain knowledge of the event of the Exodus. It’s much more profound and much more powerful than that. The verse continues, saying that we must tell it into their ears, “and you will (both) know that I am God”.
What is the goal of
education? According to Barbara
McClintock
and the Book of Exodus, Education requires: relationship, intimacy, and the recognition
of divinity in all things – both the ears of corn and the ears of
children.
-Julie
Tuesday, January 24, 2012
The Genesis of Infertility
So clearly Ami and I won't always be blogging about precisely the same topics. This is what I've been working on in my corner of our house this afternoon. It's for an upcoming anthology on topics related to sexuality for the CCAR Journal (Central Conference of American Rabbis). I'm really curious to hear your responses/reactions/thoughts!
The Genesis of
Infertility: A Contemporary Reading of Biblical Responses
Rabbi Julie Pelc
Adler
After
the first humans’ expulsion from Eden, the twin values of conception and
reproduction ceased to be as simple as would the commandment, “be fruitful and multiply”
might suggest. Sarah,
Rebecca and Rachel[1] (three of
the four matriarchs in the Torah); as well as Hannah[2]
in N’vi-im face serious challenges
trying to conceive[3]. Each woman is vocal about her struggle
in a way that befits her circumstance and personality, creating echoes that
span the generations, resounding for modern women who share their struggle.
Rachel lashes out
with words of anger, Hannah cries out to God in desperation, Isaac pleads with
God alongside Rebecca[4],
and Sarah takes matters into her own hands in order to ensure offspring for her
husband. Biblical women and their
partners confront and respond to a myriad of interconnected factors related to
infertility, struggling with the fact of their barrenness, its theological and
sociological implications, and an attempt to make meaning in their suffering.
THEOLOGIAL
The text
attributes the power of opening and closing wombs to God[5]. As God is therefore an active player in
the struggle of each of these women for fertility, their quest becomes one of
theological import. Hannah’s
prayers are perhaps the most oft mentioned, as her pleas to God are credited as
the invention of silent prayer (“Hannah was praying in her heart, and her lips
were moving but her voice was not heard”) [6].
Whereas Hannah’s
physical response to her suffering is to weep, Sarah’s is to laugh. The absurdity of the promise and the
possibility of hope so long denied must have hurt as deeply as had her years of
barrenness. Yet, Sarah is
chastised for her laughter, as if to deny its acceptability as a legitimate
emotional release to the decades of dreams deferred.
The most readily
answered prayer is that of Isaac, uttered on behalf of his wife, Rebecca[7]. She becomes pregnant seemingly right
away: “And Isaac entreated YHVH for his wife because she was barren and YHVH
was entreated of him and Rebecca his wife conceived”. The Hebrew is almost playful, using words with a lyrical
lilt and symmetry between the one requesting and the One answering the prayer[8]. Also, Rebecca is referenced twice in
the same sentence as אִשְׁתּֽוֹ׃, “his wife”, thereby emphasizing the strong
connection between the two and illustrating his active participation in
entreating God. He never abandons
hope that Rebecca, herself, might conceive (taking another wife in her stead or
chastising her for her barrenness).
God here is immediately responsive, and the couple moves from infertile
in Genesis 25:21 to expectant parents of twins in the very next verse. For Isaac and Rebecca, there
never seems to be a loss of hope or faith in God’s ability to alleviate
Rebecca’s barrenness.
Rachel, on the
other hand, seems to suffer a crisis of faith in the face of her
barrenness. Rather than to God,
Rachel cries out to her husband, Jacob, saying, “Give me children, else I die!”
Jacob seems to hear in her plea a misdirected (in his opinion) source of the
infertility and replies in anger, “Am I in God's stead, Who has withheld from
you the fruit of the womb?” [9] Jacob chastises Rachel for lashing out
in anger at him, making a demand that he sees to be completely inappropriate
and outside the range of his power to fulfill. Jacob, however, does not pray to God or make any pleas on
Rachel’s behalf. There seems to be
antagonism and resentment between these two, perhaps rooted in their shared
frustration at Rachel’s inability to conceive (especially in contrast with her
extraordinarily fertile sister and co-wife).
Interestingly,
Sarah is silent in response to her many years of barrenness, even in the face
of the seemingly absurd promise (in the face of her infertility) made to her
husband that he be the father of many descendents[10]. She, rather than pray to God, takes
definitive action to make God’s promise true. She seems to acknowledge and accept that the promise of
procreativity is made to Abraham and not to her; she seems to see her role,
instead, as the intermediary whose actions might make the promise
fulfilled. Without a word of
complaint or resentment, she offers her husband an alternative route to
fertility that includes another woman, her handmaid, in her stead as the bearer
of offspring.
SOCIAL
For women in
Biblical times, the social implications of infertility are great. In two of the four cases, other women
use their strong fertility as a tool to torment their infertile rivals. Rachel is called, עֲקָרָֽה׃, or
“barren”, in contrast with her sister, Leah, whose ease with fertility (and
resulting fecundity) torments Rachel.
Likewise, Hannah’s infertility is mentioned specifically in
counter-distinction with that of her co-wife, Peninah. Hannah weeps in response to her
suffering, so wholly at a loss and staggering with grief, she appears to the
outside eye to be drunk. This
ancient form of bullying is suggested by the text to compensate for the fact
that the infertile wives are more beloved by their husbands than their
procreating counterparts.
Sarah, too, is called barren by the text[11];
she opts to share her husband with another woman in an attempt to “give” him a
son. Jealousy between women is an issue here, too, as Sarah ultimately expels
the handmaid and her son because of an incident between her own child and the
boy that she found too disturbing to tolerate[12].
MEANINGS: RABBINIC AND
PERSONAL
Traditional
readers of text imagine meaning in each and every corner; it is not surprising,
then, that generations of rabbis noticed the abundance of infertility in the
lives of the biblical matriarchs.
Some postulated that God intentionally created the situation of barrenness so as to make each of these women
to despair her fertility, desiring the desperate pleas from these righteous
servants. In a midrash on Genesis,
the rabbis imagine that “the efficacy of prayer and the value of suffering [is]
that [it] leads to purification and brings people closer to God:” [13]
Why were the matriarchs barren?
R. Levi said in R. Shila’s name and R. Helbo in R. Johanan’s names: Because the
Holy One, blessed be He, yearns for their prayers and supplications. Thus it is
written, “O my dove, in the cranny of the rocks,/Hidden by the cliff” (Song of
Songs 2:14): Why did I make you barren? In order that, “Let Me see your
face,/Let me hear your voice” (Song of Songs 2:14).[14]
Similarly, rabbis in the Talmud,
suggest that the matriarchs and patriarchs were initially childless “because
the Holy One, blessed be He, longs to hear the prayer of the righteous.”[15]
Perhaps the
rabbinic mind was comforted by this explanation for infertility. Perhaps an afflicted couple in the
Rabbinic period would encounter this teaching, relax into their suffering,
breathing a sigh of relief, “oh, so God just wants my prayers. That explains it.” But,
somehow, I can’t imagine that this platitude worked for very long, especially
if the pleas continued and prayers for children remained unanswered (or the
divine answer was “no”). In
moments when hope wanes and doubt creeps in, I tend to prefer the company of
Sarah, Rebecca, Rachel, and Hannah.
We do not like
unanswered prayers any more than did our predecessors. We crave meaningful answers to our
questions. We want someone to
listen when we ask, “Why?” and not offer
lovingly unhelpful suggestions like, “it’ll happen when the time is right” or
“maybe you need to relax and stop thinking about it so much”. In quiet moments, we answer our own
wordless “Why?” with equally (if
not more) unhelpful answers, “God hates me” or “I’m not meant to be a mother”.
Again, our
matriarchs precede us with their own answers to try to explain that which seems
inexplicable. Genesis Rabbah 45:2 recounts,
“And Sarai said to Abram, ‘Look,
the Lord has kept me from bearing” (Gen. 16:2) as follows: “Said she, I know
the source of my affliction: It is not as people say [of a barren woman], ‘She
needs an amulet, she needs a charm,’ but ‘Look, the Lord has kept me from
bearing.’”
Sarai attributes her infertility to
God’s will. I can imagine a seemingly endless stream of well-meaning friends
and acquaintances periodically stopping by Sarai’s tent, accustomed to her
husband’s hospitality and welcoming generosity, confounded by the couple’s lack
of offspring. Each takes Sarai’s
hand, offers a long look of disbelief, and suggests, “it’ll happen when the
time is right” or “maybe you need to relax and stop thinking about it so
much”.
We are the
inheritors of a Jewish tradition steeped in the art of inquiry (and the pursuit
of questions), familiar with righteous indignation (even arguing with divine
decrees), and probing for answers wherever they might be found; we are also the
inheritors of a tradition that includes the reality of infertility. As such, we include in our search the
possibility of skepticism about the role (or existence of) God, medical
interventions heretofore impossible, and a multiplicity of media through which
conception are normative.
[1] Genesis
11:30; Genesis 25:21, 24-26; Genesis 29:31; Genesis 30:1-2, 9, 17, 22
[2] I Samuel
1:2, 5-6, 2:21
[3] Though less
is written about them, Michal in II Samuel 6:23 and the wife of Manoach in
Judges 13:2-3, 24 also struggle with infertility. Michal’s infertility is never alleviated and is unique in
that there seems to be no hope and no possible intervention for her; there is a
sense of the inevitability of her childlessness, “Michal the daughter of Saul
had no child unto the day of her death”
[4] Genesis
25:21
[5] Genesis 16:1-2;
Genesis 20:17-18; Genesis 29:31; Genesis 30:22; 1 Samuel 1:5;
[6] 1 Samuel
1:10-16
[7] Genesis
25:21
[8] The verse uses
parallel words like “vay·ye‘·tar and vay·yê·‘ā·ṯer (same verb used for that
which Isaac does and that which God does in response to the inquiry) and with
the repetition of sounds in words like Yitz·ḥāk and lə·nō·ḵach.
[9] Genesis
30:1-2
[10] Genesis
11:30,16:1-2, 21:1-3
[11] Genesis 11:30
[12] Generations
of scholars have struggled to discern the precise nature of the boy’s misdeed,
as the Hebrew verb, “metzahek” has multiple meanings
[13] “Infertile
Wife in Rabbinic Judaism”. Judith
R. Baskin. Jewish Women: A
Comprehensive Historical Encyclopedia.
Jewish Women’s Archive, 2005.
[14] Genesis
Rabbah 45:4
Un-Halachic Halachah
I swear this blog is not going to be one long anti-Haredi
screed. That’s really not what we started it for. And I promise I will sing a
new tune in the next posts I make. But I had to say this. Look at this article
I saw in the Forward today:
For the tl:dr (too long: didn't read) crowd, the long and short of it is a Haredi rabbi who basically
said that frum (Orthodox) guys-- he was talking to soldiers in Tzahal (the IDF), but the
implication seems wider than that-- should leave anywhere a woman can be heard
singing, even if they have to get shot and die for leaving. Better death than kol ishah (listening to a woman
singing).
This is insane.
This is so crazy there are no good words for it. It’s
nuttier than a Rosh Hashanah honeycake. It’s Chock Full o’ Nuts. You get my
drift?
Halachah (Jewish Law) is quite clear on the subject of
martyrdom. Basically, the rule of thumb in Jewish thought is “Choose life.”
Living is good, and one should do whatever is necessary to stay alive, and keep
others alive. That includes breaking any and all mitzvot (commandments) in
order to do so. This principle is enumerated by the Rabbis of the Talmud as pikuach nefesh docheh et ha-kol (Saving
a life trumps all other responsibilities). The only exceptions that they make
to this principle are:
- that one is not permitted to murder an innocent person to save one’s own life,
- or to publicly practice avodah zarah (idolatry) to save one’s own life,
- or to commit incest to save one’s own life.
In other words, the tradition-- which originally made the
most limited exceptions possible to the idea that one should save life at any
cost, even breaking the mitzvot-- became even clearer with time that in fact,
there is never a moment where martyrdom is truly preferable. Obviously, there
have been some brave martyrs in our tradition who chose death over apostasy, or
chose death in order to save many other lives, and we respect their courage and
convictions. But for the most part, we are crystal clear that life is so
valuable, there is nearly never anything extreme and unusual enough to justify
throwing it away. That is the halachah of the matter. End of story. And I would
have thought, until today, that every halachically educated Jew would have
agreed on that matter.
But to find that not only is this not the case, but that
some Mad Black Hatter rabbi has said that listening to a woman sing-- which is
not halachically prohibited!-- is
something a person should choose death to avoid...I am just sickened. The prohibition that the Haredim use concerning kol ishah is a chumra (legal stricture) based in aggadah (non-binding Rabbinic parable)
and in mussar (ascetic homiletic
philosophy). At best it can be taken on by individuals as a stricture over and
above the law, but it cannot be applied as a halachah for all Jews. That's just not how halachah works.
What truly sickens me isn’t just the stupidity of the
proximate issue (kol ishah, listening
to a woman sing), it’s the gross and audacious abuse of the halachic process
and paradigm that this pronouncement represents. And not just represents in and
of itself, but as an exemplar of how Haredi Judaism is abusing, perverting, and
twisting halachah while claiming their “observant” status as a mantle of
authenticity.
I have said elsewhere, and will say it again, that much of
the Haredi problem boils down to an increasing lack in Orthodoxy of the
principle of machloket l’shem shamayim
(“dispute for the sake of Heaven,” cf. BT Eruvin 13a and other places): we are
supposed to tolerate viewpoints different from our own, so long as those views
come from a place of legitimate struggle to embrace Judaism more effectively,
to better develop our understanding of what God wishes from us. We don’t have
to agree with the viewpoints of others; just tolerate them, even if we disagree
with them. And this is simply not being done.
There have been several promising voices from the Orthodox
world that have come out recently and noted that it is deeply un-Jewish to do
some of these things-- to shame people publicly, for example, or to assault
them or verbally abuse them, or to threaten their lives or health, based on a
belief that their Jewish practice or their understanding of halachah or their
theology is incorrect. But so far, no one that I have read has properly
contextualized the issue as a lack of machloket
l’shem shamayim-- although I have been pleased that some have raised the
mitzvah v’ahavta l’rei’echa kamocha (“you
must respect your fellow person as you do yourself”) which would certainly also
preclude publicly shaming and abusing one’s fellow Jews.
But in any case, part of the issue here is that non-Haredim,
and yes, non-Orthodox Jews also, have a right to their interpretations. Even if
one believes those interpretations are incorrect. The tradition dictates that
they have a place in the House of Jacob also. Instead of tolerance, the
reaction of the Haredi world is to attack, and to delegitimize not only
anything non-Haredi, but any shitah
(Jewish practice) that doesn’t include the latest round of chumrot (legal strictures) to be followed. And that includes the
increasing focus on halachic non-starters like kol ishah or much of the way that Orthodoxy currently interprets
the idea of tzniut, as I mentioned
last time.
These chumrot
would be problematic in and of themselves for their divisiveness, and the way
the Haredim are attempting to force their observance of said chumrot on everyone else; but most infuriating
is that the chumrot in question are
often beyond ridiculous.
Far too much is made in Orthodox halachah today of the
principles minhag k’halachah he (“A
custom can become like law”) and hilcheta
k’vatrai (“one should reinterpret the law according to the latest
interpretation”). These principles, if one studies the halachah, if one looks
at its development from the time of the Gemara (first five centuries CE or so)
through the time of the Rishonim (medieval period) to the early Acharonic times
(post-Renaissance period, more or less), were always guidelines. They were never intended to be either universally
applied or inflexibly applied. And they both come from times when it was
infinitely more difficult to gather Jewish text and learn enough of it to make
every halachist fully qualified. We tend to forget that for every Rabbenu
Gershom (R. Gershom b. Yehudah, 11th c.) or Rambam (R. Moshe Maimonides, 12th
c.), every Rosh (R. Asher b. Yechiel, 13th c.) or Meiri (R. Menachem Meiri,
13th c.), there were hundreds of guys running around the Jewish world being
called rabbis who had very slim educations indeed, and hundreds more acting as dayanim (halachic judges) with even less
knowledge than that. They needed interpretive guidelines that heavily influenced
their decisions, because not only did they lack training, they had few
facilities for research to make up for their lack of knowledge.
But today, even if some of our rabbis could stand extra
training in halachah and its nature, uses, and history (and I count myself on
that list, don’t worry), we at least have the benefits of having instantaneous
communication with other, more erudite rabbis; of having searchable, electronic
collections of texts like the amazing Bar Ilan Database; of having, for God’s sakes,
printed books of Jewish text that are
both readily available anywhere and (despite what Julie might say about our
library) readily affordable to even working-class Jews interested in
scholarship. It’s not only a different game, the playing field barely even
looks the same. We don’t need the same interpretive guidelines anymore-- or at
the very least, we don’t need them to be so strong.
And in the Haredi community, instead of loosening such
guidelines, to allow their highly halachically educated scholars freer rein to
use their training and talents, they are instead tightening them, setting them
in stone. And what results is not only excessive stricture without any balance
of leniency, it is bad halachah. A chumra
imposed on a chumra is
self-invalidating by halachic rules; one does not impose chumrot on the people that do not have their core bases in halachah,
but instead in aggadah (parable) or
kabbalah (mysticism) or mussar
(ascetic homiletics), or anything else: these are basic precepts of halachic interpretation.
And yet the vast majority of cases, including both issues surrounding relating
to the non-Haredi world, and surrounding tzniut,
kol ishah, the treatment of women in
general-- these precepts are ignored, if not entirely flouted.
Halachah is an amazing system. It was designed to be
innovative, evolutionary, flexible, realistic, fostering of justice and
fairness, and creative of spiritual development. Haredi halachah is none of
these things: it is rigid, completely unrealistic, creative of gross injustice
and misery, and profoundly unspiritual, innovating and evolving only
ever-increasing stricture and zealotry.
This is not what halachah is supposed to be. It is becoming
closer and closer to the antithesis of what halachah is supposed to be.
And, to my mind, what is worst is that not only does Haredi
halachah create insane chumrot like
this “death before kol ishah”
nonsense, and not only does it pervert the halachah in Orthodox communities,
but it blackens the name of halachah in the non-Orthodox world. Liberal Jews,
especially those with limited or nonexistent halachic education see these
actions, these pronouncements, and they hear them called “halachah,” and they
believe them to be authentic examples of halachic jurisprudence! And, we can
hardly be shocked to see, they then come to believe that halachah is crazy,
full of reprehensible injustices, utterly unsuited to either life in the modern
world or to Liberal Jewish observance. And I cannot blame them for thinking so,
because Haredim claim the mantle of halachic authenticity, and we do nothing to
dispute it.
But it must be disputed. People must be told, this is
not what kosher halachah is-- it's not even worthy of being called halachah. Whether in matters of life and death, or whether in
matters of who sits where on public transportation, this is not Jewish Law.
This is Haredi insanity. And the two are not the same.
-Ami
Saturday, January 21, 2012
False Modesty
As Israel and Jews all over the world have finally begun to
acknowledge the depth of the problem in the Haredi (ultra-Orthodox) communities
concerning the treatment of women and non-Haredi Jews, which include a lot of
aspects of tzniut (the “rules” of “modesty”),
I have been watching the various arguments and statements with considerable
interest.
My discomfort with the treatment of women in Orthodoxy is
one of the reasons I haven’t been Orthodox in twenty-five years. And my
discomfort with the treatment of non-Haredim by Haredim is one reason I have
never felt any attraction to that lifestyle.
These two things are actually connected in some ways, not
just independent if equally problematic phenomena.
I have written elsewhere about some of the halachic issues,
and will do so again, so for the moment, I’m going to let that side be.
Tzniut and its use
as a tool to create misogyny and oppression in the Orthodox world bother me a
lot. A whole lot. And while some might write that reaction off to my upbringing--
my mother, Rachel Adler, is also one of the mothers of modern Jewish feminist
thought-- this is not just about feminism and civil rights and other
applications of modern social and critical theory, although those schools of
thoughts make excellent points in their critiques of tzniut and the treatment of women in Orthodoxy.
This goes back to the very principle proposed in the
tradition for the founding concepts associated with tzniut. The idea that by women exposing too much of themselves, or
doing things that could be perceived as sensual, they will cause men to become
distracted by their yitzrei ha-ra
(the urge “to do evil,” or probably more accurately, “for chaos”). Men, then
thinking of sex, will stop studying Torah and praying and other holy stuff, and
instead will do unthinkable and perverse things in the quest to slake their
unquenchable concupiscent lusts, which apparently guys are universally prone to
do....
The basic premise is flawed. Deeply flawed. Leaving aside,
for the moment, the questionable premise that all men barely restrain vast
arrays of unquenchable concupiscent lusts which can be set loose at any moment
by the sight of a passing uncovered ankle, the fundamental idea put forth by
these rabbis in our tradition is that because every man struggles with his yetzer (his drives), women need to cover
themselves from head to toe, cover their hair, shut up, and, at some key
moments, hide behind walls. (I could, of course, also mention that this whole
scenario is a fairly ridiculous principle to the 10% or so of the Jewish People
who are gay. But that’s another conversation, I think.)
But the thing is, that’s not how to master your yetzer. Self-control, self-discipline
(both mental and emotional) and spiritual focus are not created by trying to
control the world around you. They are created by exerting some measure of
control on the world within. As any recovering alcoholic will tell you, you
don’t stop drinking by trying to ensure that no one around you drinks and you
never encounter alcohol. You stop drinking by deciding that alcohol will not
control your life, and you will not drink it: regardless of what others may do;
regardless of the situation you are in. This, my friends, is what it looks like
to master your yetzer for something.
And since most people are not actually sex addicts, the
principle should be all the better in its application to their lives, where it
should be easier for them to come to control themselves and their sexual
desires.
Not only is what the Haredim are doing in their communities
in Israel and in America wrong for all the usual feminist/civil rights reasons,
it’s wrong because it is, spiritually, an utter failure.
Instead of mastering their yitzarim, Haredim are obsessed with sex: not necessarily in the
ways that we non-Haredim might recognize, but in their own ways. Non-Orthodox
people often find it literally unbelievable how much time in the Haredi world
is spent dealing with workarounds to prevent men and women spending too much
time together, or time alone together, or touching each other in utterly benign
and innocent ways, or generally keeping women silenced, covered, and locked
into kitchen-and-cradle social roles, away from where men spend most of their
time. I could write pages describing the insane chumrot (legal strictures) created over the past forty-odd years
that have collectively moved Haredi Judaism from merely conservative (small
“c”) to absolutely clinical when it comes to women and sexuality, and it would
still be hard to believe if one hasn’t seen it all in action.
But, because of the ever-increasing rigidity and
inflexibility of Orthodox halachic understanding, and the lack in that world of
any real application of machloket l’shem
shamayim (“dispute for the sake of Heaven,” cf. BT Eruvin 13a and
elsewhere), this utter failure of an attempt to create spiritual discipline
within individuals by social engineering has now become enshrined as halachah l’Moshe mi-Sinai (“laws given to
Moses at Sinai”). But it is not so: it is a perversion of halachah and
tradition. It has to go.
To master your yetzer,
you must direct focus inward, not outward. You must be confronted, regularly,
with the thing to which your yetzer
drives you, so that you become accustomed to its presence, and are able to
control your reactions.
This is one thing in which the Jews of the non-Orthodox
world excel their Haredi fellows at doing. To put it another way, non-Orthodox
shuls (synagogues) have no mechitzas
(walls or other barriers separating the women and the men): on the contrary,
men and women sit together. And both sexes wear less clothing than their Haredi
counterparts-- even in very straitlaced non-Orthodox congregations. And I am
sure that all my non-Orthodox readers will concur with me when I say that in
twenty-plus years of davening
(praying) at non-Orthodox shuls, I have never once seen a man break off in the
middle of his prayers, grab a passing woman, and shout, “I can’t take it
anymore, I gotta have you now!”
Have I seen a fair amount of idle chat instead of prayer?
Yes: and I’ve seen the same thing amongst men in Orthodox shuls. Have I seen
people praying together in amicable community, focused on tefillah (prayer) and Torah? Yes. In both Orthodox and non-Orthodox
shuls. But never have I seen someone surrender to his yetzer because he happened to be near women-- even very attractive
women. And while this may have something to do with the virtues of the people I
have seen, it probably has mostly to do with the fact that in the non-Orthodox
world, men and women are often together: often work together, do recreational
activities together, often have casual contact with one another, and are
accustomed to interacting with those of the opposite sex and even to seeing
them in attractive and sometimes revealing clothing. And even those of us who
are not able to consistently ignore the existence of attractive individuals of
the opposite sex are at least able to put such thoughts aside long enough to
sit through a service without being distracted into hypersexualized apoplexy.
That may not be “mastering” your yetzer, but
it’s a step on the road. And it’s certainly a better step than saying “I am
tempted! The solution is for you to be less tempting!”
Tzniut as it is
currently understood has got to go, not merely for reasons of rights and
freedoms, but for spiritual ones as well. That’s what it comes down to.
-Ami
Thursday, January 19, 2012
The "Freedom" of the Exodus
It seems appropriate to me that Julie and I are starting
this blog while the annual Torah reading cycle is more or less at the beginning
of the book of Shmot (Exodus), with the narrative of Yetziat Mitzrayim (the
Exodus from Egypt).
Yetziat Mitzrayim, aside from the national genesis of the
Jewish People, is the true beginning of the Covenant between God and Israel.
There would be no Sinai without the Exodus, and there could be no Torah without
our freedom. That’s not just two ways of saying the same thing.
In the twenty-sixth verse of the seventh chapter of Shmot
(Parashat Va’era), Moshe Rabbeinu (our teacher Moses) instructs Pharaoh ko amar Hashem: shlach et ‘ami vaya’avduni. “Thus
says Hashem: send forth my people, so that they may serve me.”
It’s worth noting that this verse is often only partially
quoted: “Let my people go!” says Charleton Heston to Yul Brynner, or sings Paul
Robeson with basso mournfulness. But the problem with ending the sentence there
is that that wasn’t the deal. The freedom that we were given was not the
freedom of anarchic self-determination without bound or limit. It was the
freedom to leave a situation wherein we had no right or power but to do as we
were told suited the whims of Pharaoh, with no other ends for us to serve but
his pleasure; and instead, to willingly take upon ourselves, as an entire and
united people, a covenant between ourselves and God, wherein the ends desired
are the establishment and furtherance of a just society for the People Israel,
the modeling of the same for the aid of other societies to become more just,
and the dedication of ourselves and our descendants forever to an attempt to
elevate all of us in holiness, and develop spiritual awareness and enrichment
in every individual among us.
Freedom, in other words, is not entirely free. It includes
the obligations of a framework of social responsibilities, and the commitment
to goals of a very long-term and deep nature. Freedom which lacks those things,
which is free of all responsibilities, of all obligations between people or
between ourselves and God, is not actually such a wonderful thing: as Kris
Kristofferson sang, some years ago, “Freedom’s just another word for nothin’
left to lose. Nothin’ ain’t worth nothin’, but it’s free.” And while there may be
a certain exhilaration that can come with having no ties to anyone or anything,
and living purely in and for the moment, it is not particularly sustaining of
either human relationships or social justice. Which is why the freedom that
Kris Kristofferson sang about (and, yes, Janis Joplin sang about too, since her
cover is probably better known than the original) is not what we mean by
freedom in the narrative of Yetziat Mitzrayim.
Our freedom is not just a freedom from something, but freedom to
something.
When we left Egypt it was to go to Sinai. When we came to
Sinai, it was to enter into the covenant of Torah with God. When we left Sinai,
it was to take our place as a covenanted nation and begin our share of the work
in the covenant. God did his part by giving prophets prophecy and setting us on
the path that would become the Judaism we all recognize today, and that will
become whatever the Judaism of tomorrow’s tomorrow will look like. Our part was
to accept the covenant, and then, when prophecy came to an end, to take up the
reins of Torah and begin to make more of it-- a right and duty that we have
embodied in the process of halachic interpretation, as we learn in the Talmud,
Bava Metzia 59a (the Tanur shel Achnai incident).
We sometimes forget that our primary duty is the creation of
Torah. And since Torah, in its widest sense, is not only Torah she’bich’tav (Written Torah), but Torah she’b’al peh (Oral Torah), which can include halachah (Jewish
Law, although the term is broader than the usual translation implies: “The Way
of the Jews” might be a better translation), aggadah and midrash (exegetical and homiletical parables), kabbalah
(mysticism), minhag (customs), tefillah (liturgy), parshanut (commentary), and all the other aspects, details,
nuances, embellishments, and creations of our sacred tradition, that gives us a
palette of epic proportions to use, and a canvas incapable of completion upon
which to work.
When we use our freedom to observe the mitzvot
(commandments), to expand and interpret Jewish Law, to try and improve Jewish
society and the societies around us with justice, compassion, lovingkindness,
and respectful tolerance in disagreement and dispute, we make Torah, and we carry
out our role in the covenant. In this way, we live our lives in fulfillment of
the entirety of the verse ko amar Hashem:
shlach et ‘ami vaya’avduni. “Thus says Hashem: send forth my people, so
that they may serve me.”
-Ami
"LET MY PEOPLE GO"
“LET MY PEOPLE GO!”
It may be the single most effective political campaign in history.
“LET MY PEOPLE GO!”
From Moshe Rabeinu to the Reverend Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. in the mid-twentieth century and beyond, the words, “LET MY PEOPLE GO!” are synonymous with a public outcry on behalf of an enslaved people. “LET MY PEOPLE GO!” is a motivator, a call to action, a call to conscience!
But then what? We rarely hear what comes immediately afterwards. The rest of the verse from Exodus ch.10, v.3, is שלח עמי ויעבדני– “shalach ami v’ya-ahv-dooni” The Hebrew word, Ya-ahv-dooni, comes from the same root as the word for slave, eved: עָבַד. This “extra” word, v’ya-ahv-dooni, adds a completely different sentiment to the oft repeated, “LET MY PEOPLE GO!” It adds an explanation for what might come after the liberation.
Mostly, v’ya-ahv-dooni is translated, “THAT THEY MIGHT WORSHIP ME” But throughout the TaNaKh, this root word עָבַד. is used to describe various forms of labor: English translations range from “cultivate”, “till”, “make servant” and “impose”. The people doing this work are referred to as in “bondage”, “laborers”, and “workers”. Somehow, “LET MY PEOPLE GO SO THAT THEY MIGHT BE WORKERS” doesn’t have the same effect as simply the outcry, “LET MY PEOPLE GO!” without a caveat of any obligation that the newly freed individuals will be expected to do in exchange for their liberation.
It seems paradoxical that the freed slaves (avadim) must be set free so that they might work (ya-ahv-dooni). But there is something unique and important that is lost when we truncate Moshe’s message to Pharoah in Exodus 10:3. “LET MY PEOPLE GO!” may well be a motivational message advocating for drastic change from the status quo, it may be an outcry by the people to an oppressor and a slogan to unite a group as they prepare to rise up against abuses of power, but it does not inspire the people or give them any guidelines on how to choose a better life for themselves once they’ve been freed.
The brilliance of שלח עמי ויעבדני– “shalach ami v’ya-ahv-dooni is that it takes the people from where they are – slaves – avadim and it subtly and gently suggests how they might transform themselves into free people, who might learn to use the same root letters for that which subjugated them to an oppressive power, Pharoah, to become people who might work for a higher good as free people who may worship God. “Ya-ahv-dooni” is an offering by God to the people of a passageway to true freedom. Only free people can choose to worship God, to be laborers for truth and justice, or follow a path of good deeds and loving-kindness. “Ya-ahv-dooni” is a suggestion, not a command.
“THAT THEY MIGHT WORSHIP ME” is a hope, a dream uttered by a Divine voice thinking wistfully of a future time wherein the freed Israelites will no longer be avadim to Pharoah in Egypt, but instead will choose to take the raw materials of their subjugation and transform themselves into human beings with free will – choosing to worship the One True God – and to follow ways of righteousness. Again and again throughout the Torah (and beginning almost immediately after the Exodus), we are instructed to remember: Avadim hayyinu – we were slaves in Egypt.
And now, it is up to us to choose: for Whom will we labor?
-Julie
It may be the single most effective political campaign in history.
“LET MY PEOPLE GO!”
From Moshe Rabeinu to the Reverend Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. in the mid-twentieth century and beyond, the words, “LET MY PEOPLE GO!” are synonymous with a public outcry on behalf of an enslaved people. “LET MY PEOPLE GO!” is a motivator, a call to action, a call to conscience!
But then what? We rarely hear what comes immediately afterwards. The rest of the verse from Exodus ch.10, v.3, is שלח עמי ויעבדני– “shalach ami v’ya-ahv-dooni” The Hebrew word, Ya-ahv-dooni, comes from the same root as the word for slave, eved: עָבַד. This “extra” word, v’ya-ahv-dooni, adds a completely different sentiment to the oft repeated, “LET MY PEOPLE GO!” It adds an explanation for what might come after the liberation.
Mostly, v’ya-ahv-dooni is translated, “THAT THEY MIGHT WORSHIP ME” But throughout the TaNaKh, this root word עָבַד. is used to describe various forms of labor: English translations range from “cultivate”, “till”, “make servant” and “impose”. The people doing this work are referred to as in “bondage”, “laborers”, and “workers”. Somehow, “LET MY PEOPLE GO SO THAT THEY MIGHT BE WORKERS” doesn’t have the same effect as simply the outcry, “LET MY PEOPLE GO!” without a caveat of any obligation that the newly freed individuals will be expected to do in exchange for their liberation.
It seems paradoxical that the freed slaves (avadim) must be set free so that they might work (ya-ahv-dooni). But there is something unique and important that is lost when we truncate Moshe’s message to Pharoah in Exodus 10:3. “LET MY PEOPLE GO!” may well be a motivational message advocating for drastic change from the status quo, it may be an outcry by the people to an oppressor and a slogan to unite a group as they prepare to rise up against abuses of power, but it does not inspire the people or give them any guidelines on how to choose a better life for themselves once they’ve been freed.
The brilliance of שלח עמי ויעבדני– “shalach ami v’ya-ahv-dooni is that it takes the people from where they are – slaves – avadim and it subtly and gently suggests how they might transform themselves into free people, who might learn to use the same root letters for that which subjugated them to an oppressive power, Pharoah, to become people who might work for a higher good as free people who may worship God. “Ya-ahv-dooni” is an offering by God to the people of a passageway to true freedom. Only free people can choose to worship God, to be laborers for truth and justice, or follow a path of good deeds and loving-kindness. “Ya-ahv-dooni” is a suggestion, not a command.
“THAT THEY MIGHT WORSHIP ME” is a hope, a dream uttered by a Divine voice thinking wistfully of a future time wherein the freed Israelites will no longer be avadim to Pharoah in Egypt, but instead will choose to take the raw materials of their subjugation and transform themselves into human beings with free will – choosing to worship the One True God – and to follow ways of righteousness. Again and again throughout the Torah (and beginning almost immediately after the Exodus), we are instructed to remember: Avadim hayyinu – we were slaves in Egypt.
And now, it is up to us to choose: for Whom will we labor?
-Julie
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)